Tuesday, 22 March 2011

A second time in Second Life (with Haven Winton*)

I first heard about Second Life three years ago through a friend who had got hooked. He told me all about the virtual world, how it works, how you could move around, interact with other avatars, attend seminars, listen to virtual buskers and ‘live your other life’ and all (or almost all) for free. That was enough to tempt me to have a look but I ended up disappointed. Perhaps the experience was spoiled for me by the fact that I was playing World of Warcraft at the time. Compared to the fantasy world of Azeroth where I would travel with my Blood Elf Paladin and complete heroic quests, Second Life just seemed so … dull!

On top of the lack of a goal or game-playing aim, the graphics seemed poor, the whole thing ran so slowly and some of the other avatars around were just plain weird (of course, elves, dwarves and orcs in World of Warcraft are also weird but at least they are in context)! And so, I uninstalled the application after just a day and never entertained any thoughts of returning.

Until, that is, Second Life kept being mentioned by colleagues on my MA as a mode of online instruction. By chance, one of those colleagues was Nergiz Kern who had been heavily involved in teaching in Second Life for a while. Her experiences got me interested from an educational perspective and starting a course entitled Teaching and Learning Online provided the final push to start up again.

Playing Around

Our first session in Second Life was all about navigating the environment and manipulating objects. I think my experiences from games like Warcraft helped as I quickly got used to the basic controls and had a kind of intuitive feel for using the keyboard and mouse. In virtual environments, ı like to test the limits of what my character/avatar can do so I was soon sitting on top of walls and signposts. A brief tutorial in how to edit objects led to me creating this giant penguin (if you are a regular SL user and you see one coming, it’s most likely me)!

Snapshot_004

Scavenger Hunt

The second session in SL included a group task in which we were sent to various locations to retrieve information in the style of a scavenger hunt. My group visited a Science Centre and a Greek island, where we all ended up for a drink on the terrace and a post-task reflective chat.

molecules_004 (2)

The ability to engage in voice chat was invaluable and really added to a sense of ‘being there’ and interacting together. This clearly has benefits for language instruction but I remain unconvinced for the following reasons:

  • Unless you are dealing with seasoned SL users or tech-savvy folk familiar with 3D virtual worlds, a lot of training will be needed before you can get onto the learning tasks.
  • I sometimes missed important bits of information due to trying to get my character to wave, point or some such other gesture.
  • There are a lot of other distractions - I nearly missed the second session because I was exploring a ski resort!
  • As I work with kids, SL is of no immediate use to me (age restrictions). Despite the affordances offered, it’s just not for everyone.

Hmmm, plenty to ponder over a Tequila Sunrise!

molecules_003 (2)

*Haven Winton is my avatar name in case you hadn’t figured it out. Winking smile

2 comments:

  1. I have to admit, much like you earlier, I've never gotten into or even investigated Second Life, largely due to it being completely unheard of over here, but also because the little exposure to the graphical side of it has reminded me of a very outdated Sims game. I'm certain that if so many colleagues use it for some sort of instruction, it must have redeeming characteristics, but I think I'm just not well-versed enough to bother. Until I see a clear purpose (like I need to use it to attend some event), I'm not sure that'll change.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, as I said in the post, the time investment required to get the nost out of it would be considerable. That's true not only of the learner but of the teacher as well. Like you, I doubt I'll become a regular unless some specific purpose comes along...

    ...but then I guess I wouldn't be the right guy for the job anyway :p

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for commenting! Your comment will appear after Dave has approved it. :-)